|Articles|February 1, 2012

Applied Clinical Trials

  • Applied Clinical Trials-02-01-2012
  • Volume 21
  • Issue 2

Give the Patient a Clear Voice

Author(s)Jean Paty

All measurements and outcomes need to reflect what is happening with the patient.

I cannot believe FDA did it again. For two years in a row, FDA comes out as the leader, pushing our industry forward. At the end of 2010, we thanked FDA for encouraging us to listen to the patient. This came through loud and clear in FDA's publication and promotion of their patient reported outcome (PRO) guidance at the end of 2009. PROs are direct reports from the patients that are not interpreted by a health professional. The propagation of PROs across product development programs, and the appearance of new PRO-based labels in the past two years is clear evidence we in the industry are hearing FDA's message.

Jean Paty

In 2011, FDA went yet another step by telling us that there are multiple ways to give the patient a clear voice in clinical research. Specifically, FDA stated that we need to ensure all of our measurements and outcomes, not just PROs, reflect what is happening with the patient. In other words, we need to provide evidence that all of our instruments or tools measure what we think they measure. In FDA terminology, we must ensure that instruments or tools and their related outcome measures are fit for purpose in their context of use.

Specifically, this means that instruments based upon a clinician's evaluation of a patient (ClinROs), and measures taken by an observer (ObsROs), like a mother reporting about her child, are subject to the same requirements for reliability and validity as PROs. FDA expects that all outcomes assessments (OAs)—ClinROs, ObsROs, and PROs—will meet 21CFR314.126(b)(6) requirements that "the methods of assessment of subjects' response are well-defined and reliable." The recommendations of how to meet the well-defined and reliable standard are delineated in the PRO guidance. In other words, FDA is using the PRO guidance as the yardstick by which it measures all OAs.

The announcement regarding OAs came during an FDA-sponsored workshop held on October 19, 2011 at the FDA White Oak Campus in Silver Spring, MD. Both FDA and the industry were represented at this one day workshop. Janet Woodcock, MD, Director of the Center for Drug Evaluation and Research, gave the opening address and set the stage for OAs:

"Now clinical trial outcome assessments are one type of drug development tool that we have identified as ripe for improvement. The identification, development, and qualification of new clinical trial outcome assessments is an area that has really not been aggressively pursued by the scientific community, and the lack of—the consequent lack of assessment tools has been impeding, I think, the successful development of new drugs because we really in many cases don't know how to measure the impacts, both for good and ill, of the drugs that we test in people. And we can do better."

This challenge from Woodcock also provides opportunity. OAs that are well-defined and reliable can support novel labels for our products, which in turn differentiate them from other treatments. There is now a defined regulatory pathway to novel product labeling.

It is refreshing to see that regulators are prepared to help us in the industry meet the challenges of bringing new products to market, and most important, to create a pathway of success for these products. What do you have planned for 2012, FDA?

Jean Paty, Senior Vice President, invivodata, Inc. www.invivodata.com

Articles in this issue

almost 15 years ago

Pharmacovigilance Alliances

almost 15 years ago

PPD Trains CRAs in Three Dimensions

almost 15 years ago

Business and News Update February 2012

almost 15 years ago

Looking Beyond the Euro Turmoil

almost 15 years ago

Strategic Partnership

almost 15 years ago

Leveraging the Transition

Related to this article

The Next Evolution of Patient-Centered Trials Starts with Design
Decentralized trial success depends less on how far activities move away from sites than on matching each activity’s delivery model to participant burden, site readiness, and data integrity, using patient intelligence to decide where flexibility helps and where site-based care remains essential.
© putilov_denis - © putilov_denis - stock.adobe.com
Sponsors rigorously vet CROs for oncology expertise but rarely apply the same scrutiny to the IRB reviewing their trials, even though increasingly complex protocols require reviewers with substantive therapeutic knowledge, not just a rostered oncologist.
Closing the Community Access Gap: Q&A with Kent Thoelke, Paradigm Health
In this Q&A, Kent Thoelke, CEO of Paradigm Health, discusses why participation gaps in community and rural settings come down to both patient cost barriers and site infrastructure, how legacy workflows weigh on community clinics, and what policy and technology changes it would take to make clinical research a real care option for more patients.